Top 5 Mistakes to Avoid When Choosing a Prep School for Athletics

Choosing a prep school can be a very stressful time for players and their families.  I have been involved with many families in their decision making and here are some mistakes one wants to avoid when choosing a prep school.

1) Choosing based on only tuition – Prep school tuition can be expensive.  When some families are deciding between multiple schools they end up choosing the one based solely on the price of tuition.  The school that is a better fit might cost more but they only see the net tuition amount.  This is an area where basketball academies take advantage of families with more affordable tuition.  But this is where the cliché “you get what you pay for” often presents itself.

2) Listening to a friend, teammate, or trainer about the one prep school they are familiar with – Everyone has heard of at least one prep school.  Ask any player if they know one and they will mention some of the programs that have sent multiple players to the NBA.  Did you know that there are around 100 prep schools that offer a post-grad year?  While it is great that a neighbor knows a kid, who went to a prep school, that does not mean that this program is the right fit for each person.  I find out when talking to players and their families that so many have chosen a school because it was recommended by someone who doesn’t know the entire landscape of the prep school world.  If this choice works out, great.  But there are many times it doesn’t.  Do your research, call around, or reach out to me.  I can help connect you to the right fitting schools.

3) Not knowing the difference between a brick + mortar prep school and a basketball academy – See this article for a detailed overview on the differences between the two options.  It is very important to know that basketball academies are not prep schools.  They do provide a place to do a post grad year, but each player looking at this option needs to do their due diligence.

4 Unrealistic expectations of what a prep school can provide – These are crazy times during Covid.  Getting placed at the college level is harder than it has ever been.  Now is the time to have a prep school coach advocating for you.  The rolodex of college coaches that each prep school coach has is impressive. However just because a prep school coach knows Larry Brown, doesn’t mean he can get you a scholarship to Memphis.  Some families reach out to me stating that they are D1 or bust.  I like having that goal, as I had it myself growing up.  But with it being tougher and tougher to find a spot at the college level, all families need to be realistic of what a prep school can provide.  A player could spend $65,000 and nine months at a prep school and not end up at their dream school.  A prep school year is not a guarantee of getting the exact school you want.  But you will be placed at the right fitting program at the time.  During these uncertain times I would put my faith in a prep school coach for placement.  In addition to placement, a player will receive all the other benefits of attending a prep school: academics, improvement on the court, emotional maturity, being around other cultures, etc.

5) Waiting too long – There are only so many roster spots at prep schools and so much financial aid.  Some prep schools fill their rosters by April.  Some have roster openings up until the school year starts.  If a player waits too long they will have less options and less aid available.  I was still getting inquiries for prep schools up until December of this year.  If you are wanting to do a prep school year don’t wait.  Just so you know, college coaches are not recruiting high school games now.  So many players and their families that reach out to me wait until after the season to start looking at prep schools.  They were waiting for a college coach to give them an offer during the season.  Then it is a mad dash to find post- grad options.  If prep school is not an option here is an article I wrote on other alternatives.

PODCASTS

Bryce Daley: Coach of Salisbury on How to Get Recruited for Basketball and Post-Grad Years

Bryce Daley, coach at Salisbury School, shares how to get recruited for basketball, what families should know about a post grad year for basketball, and how prep school can help players prepare for college.

Bill Hanzlik: Former Nugget on What NBA Teams Look For & Choosing Prep School for His Son

https://youtu.be/Mwc-6r8lHv8 Audio Only Download Listen On Apple  Listen On Spotify Listen On Amazon ▶️ Show Notes What NBA teams look for goes beyond talent. Former Denver Nugget Bill Hanzlik joins PREP Athletics to talk about player potential, work ethic,...

Garvin McAlister: Millbrook’s Head Coach on Playing Multiple Sports & Athlete Development

Garvin shares his insights on student-athlete development tips, multi-sport training, and preparing high school athletes for success both on and off the court.

Paul Biancardi, ESPN National Director of Recruiting, featured on a PREP Athletics podcast thumbnail with a high school basketball gym background.

Paul Biancardi: ESPN Recruiting Director on What Coaches Really Want

ESPN’s Paul Biancardi joins the PREP Athletics Podcast to reveal what college coaches look for in recruits and how to stand out in the scouting process.

George White, founder of RecruitU and former D1 coach, discussing NCAA’s 5-and-5 rule on the PREP Athletics Podcast, with a basketball player in action and a crowd in the background.

George White: D1 Coach Breaks Down NCAA’s New Eligibility Rules

Former Harvard player & D1 coach George White breaks down the NCAA’s 5-and-5 rule and its impact on prep basketball.

Promotional thumbnail for Prep Athletics Podcast featuring John Carroll and Jason Smith with the Masters Academy International logo and a basketball gym background.

Jason Smith & John Carroll: How MAI is Redefining Basketball Development

Jason Smith & John Carroll reveal how MAI is revolutionizing prep basketball with elite training, academics, and college placement.

Avon Old Farms Head Coach Matt Mihalich and a player in action during a basketball game, featured on the PREP Athletics Podcast.

Matt Mihalich: Avon Old Farms Coach on Playing Time, Reclassifying, and College Placement

Get insider prep hoops tips from Avon Old Farms Coach Matt Mihalich on playing time, reclassifying & college placement—only on PREP Athletics.

Cory Heitz of PREP Athletics in a grey suit against a cinematic high school basketball gym background with "Recruitment Insider Tips"

Cory Heitz: Prep School Recruiting & NCAA Rule Changes Explained

Cory Heitz updates on the Final Four showcase, the new MAI program, and advice on navigating prep school second teams and NCAA eligibility rule changes.

Robert Icart on the PREP Athletics Podcast discussing AAU basketball truths, featuring a high school basketball player in a BTI jersey driving to the hoop in a crowded gym.

Robert Icart: 25+ Years of AAU Wisdom—How to Pick the Right Team & Prep School

Robert Icart shares 25+ years of AAU wisdom on picking the right team, the benefits of prep school post-grad years, and building life skills after basketball.

Coach Jim Driggs of Albany Academy Basketball on the Prep Athletics Podcast discussing NEPSAC recruitment and player development.

Jim Driggs: Albany Academy Coach on Prep School Basketball Truths

Coach Jim Driggs discusses Albany Academy’s move to NEPSAC AA , reclassification benefits , and the toughness needed for D1 basketball.

ARTICLES

Inside MAI: A New Model for Prep Basketball

Inside MAI’s new prep basketball model, built around player development, academics, recovery, college placement, and the full student-athlete experience.

The NCAA’s New Rule: What Players and Parents Need to Know

Learn how the NCAA’s proposed 5-and-5 rule could impact recruiting, NIL, transfers, post-grad years, and college athlete eligibility.

What Prep Schools Really Look for in Basketball Recruits in 2026

Discover what prep school basketball coaches really look for in recruits in 2026. St. George’s coach Dwayne Pina shares insights on player development, Ivy League recruiting, AA prep basketball, the transfer portal, and what separates Division I athletes.

How Prep School Can Change a Player’s Recruiting Path

How one prep school year transformed Antonio Anderson’s recruiting path, and why the right environment can change everything for overlooked players.

Prep school basketball guard handling the ball in a packed gym with text explaining what it takes to become a Division I guard in 2026.

What It Takes to Be a D1 Guard in 2026

A D1 coach details the skills, habits, and mindset college staffs demand from point guards, from pick-and-roll IQ to defense, film study, and leadership.

Prep school basketball player in game action with bold text reading “Coach’s Model: Wait or Commit,” highlighting a recruiting decision framework.

Post-Grads: Commit or Wait? A Coach’s Model

Former D1, NBA, and Ivy League coach breaks down modern recruiting, NIL realities, early commitments, best-fit schools, and smart paths families miss.

High school basketball player shooting in game action with bold text reading “High School Recruiting: Post-Grad vs JUCO,” highlighting a recruiting pathway comparison.

Post-Grad vs JUCO vs High School Recruiting

Compare post-grad prep, JUCO, and high school through a coach’s lens, and learn how age, habits, and readiness shape recruiting speed in the portal era.

High school basketball player in game action with bold text reading “NEPSAC AA vs AAA vs A: Which Level Fits Your Path?” highlighting prep school league differences.

NEPSAC AA vs AAA vs A: Which Level Fits Your Path?

Understand the real differences between NEPSAC A, AA, and AAA, how playing time and competition impact development, and which level fits your recruiting path.

High school basketball player in game action with bold text highlighting “Post-Grad Year Full Student,” representing academic and athletic expectations in prep school programs.

Prep School Post-Grad Year Requirements and Academics: What Families Must Know

Learn how prep schools treat post-grads as full-time students, how academic placement works, and why coursework still matters during a post-grad hoops year.

Prep school basketball player in game action with message emphasizing that development wins over star rankings in the prep school process.

Basketball Rankings vs Reality: Why Development Wins Over Stars

Learn how basketball rankings are created, why chasing them backfires, and where players should invest their energy to actually get discovered and recruited.

FIND YOUR FIT

Find Your Fit

Get Your Free Personalized Prep School Assessment

Finding the right prep school basketball opportunity starts with understanding your complete situation. Our free assessment collects key information about your athletic abilities, academic standing, and financial considerations to provide targeted guidance specific to your circumstances. This approach allows us to cut through the recruitment noise and give you honest, practical feedback about your options. Most families find that this comprehensive evaluation saves them time and helps avoid mismatched programs that waste valuable development years.

Get Your Free Personalized Prep School Assessment

Finding the right prep school basketball opportunity starts with understanding your complete situation. Our free assessment collects key information about your athletic abilities, academic standing, and financial considerations to provide targeted guidance specific to your circumstances. This approach allows us to cut through the recruitment noise and give you honest, practical feedback about your options. Most families find that this comprehensive evaluation saves them time and helps avoid mismatched programs that waste valuable development years.

QUESTIONS?

Questions?

Fill out the form below, and we’ll get back to you within 24-48 hours, or feel free to reach out via email to cory@prepathletics.com. We look forward to hearing from you!

Fill out the form below, and we’ll get back to you within 24-48 hours, or feel free to reach out via email to cory@prepathletics.com. We look forward to hearing from you!